Showing posts with label defamation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label defamation. Show all posts

Saturday, November 21, 2026

There is No Such Thing as Unfettered Free Speech

Several years ago, I wrote an article concerning social media posts and how people making ill-conceived posts could see their posts come back and bite them if they were ever in a defensive incident. Posts on social networking sites such as Facebook, Reddit, “X”, Instagram, blogs, and other social media venues are regularly popping up as evidence in courtrooms across the country. Social media evidence has been a critical element in numerous use of force court cases.

If you have any doubt, watch The First 48, a television series on A&E filmed in various cities in the United States. This program follows real homicide investigations. One of the first thing that homicide investigators do as they begin many investigations is look at the victim’s and possible perpetrator’s social media. Prosecutors and defense attorneys have learned that searching people’s social networking and combing though some of what they have shared with the rest of the world is often a veritable gold mine of information. In several trials, a defendant’s credibility was completely lost in a matter of seconds when the jury was presented with something the defendant had previously written in text messages or posted on social media.

However, there is no such thing as unfettered free speech and you do not need to be involved in a defensive incident to find yourself in hot water over a social media post. In November 2026, Pinellas County Sheriff’s deputies arrested a retired NYPD officer living in Florida after he allegedly posted a social media message calling for the “beheading” of a Pinellas County commissioner who voted to approve an expansion of a local mosque.(1)

Rodolfo Mienert Booking Photo (PCSO)
Rodolfo Mienert is accused of commenting on Facebook under the username “Rudy MineAllmine,” and attacking the commissioner’s support for a land-use change involving the North Pinellas Mosque. A Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office statement indicated that Mienert called the commissioner a “Republican turncoat” and then wrote, “off with his head!” PCSO Detectives traced the account’s IP address to Mienert, who later acknowledged that he was the account’s owner.

Mienert was promptly arrested and charged with one felony count of making a written or electronic threat to kill. The charge carries a maximum sentence of 15 years in a Florida prison.

So, a retired NYPD Sergeant is now facing up to fifteen years in prison for making a statement that he likely considered an exercise of his first amendment right of free speech. It is highly likely that Mienert had no intention of directly threatening the commissioner with cutting off his head. However, others could and did take his “off with his head!” seriously. Pinellas County Sheriff Bob Gualtieri stated that “threatening to cut off the head of a county commissioner because of his vote on a land issue is intolerable and we will strictly enforce the law against anyone who makes threats of this nature.”

People often believe that social media is a venue to say anything that comes to mind without repercussions. This is absolutely not the case; you cannot say anything you want on social media as a traditional exercise of the free speech right.

Indeed the concept of “defamation” has a long history and many legal systems have long considered defamation to be an actionable wrong in various forms. A study of defamation lawsuits filed in the United States from 2020 to mid-2026 estimated that between 485 and 646 lawsuits for defamation were filed in state courts over social media posts.(2) This number is likely a low estimate because no central database exists. I did find a website, The Digital Media Law Project (3), that has a database containing records of social media-linked lawsuits from 2000 to 2014 
(it is no longer updated). The database has records from 2006-2013 concerning 280 lawsuits filed over blog posts; records from 2000-2013 concerning 266 lawsuits filed over forum posts; and 420 lawsuits from 2000-2014 over website posts and e-mails.

Although the remedy for verbal and written defamation has typically been through the civil legal system, in the United States threatening speech and hate speech are now addressed in criminal law and the punishments for violations can be very severe as NYPD Sergeant Retired Mienert has probably discovered. 
 
Further, the fact that the legal system in some states tolerates people of certain political views routinely posting death threats to political and business figures does not mean that this standard applies everywhere.
 
Clearly, before we post on any venue (including “private” e-mail lists) we should consider exactly how what we post could be twisted or taken out of context. Once there is an electronic record of something it likely will live forever in some form, it is difficult, potentially impossible, to make it go away. 

(1) Internewscast; 
Retired NYPD Officer Arrested Over Florida Mosque Expansion Threat; https://internewscast.com/news/us/retired-nypd-officer-arrested-over-florida-mosque-expansion-threat/ 
 
(2) The Defamation Expert Witness; Social Media Defamation Lawsuits Are Increasing: U.S. Statistics, Data & Trends; https://thedefamation.expert/social-media-defamation-lawsuits-are-increasing-u-s-statistics-data-trends/
 
(3) The Digital Media Law Project; https://www.dmlp.org/database